The Greatest Grid


The 1811 Plan

The Commissioners

The three commissioners were prominent men with achievements relevant to their task to lay out New York City’s future. Gouverneur Morris and his half-nephew-in-law, John Rutherford, were wealthy lifetime residents of the New York City area with long histories in land administration and business affairs. Albany resident Simeon De Witt was among the most accomplished surveyors in the country.

A more difficult question is why they were commissioners. Read More There is no record of why these three men were selected, who selected or promoted them, who else, if anyone, was under consideration, whether they or other possible commissioners solicited their own appointments, or what prior understandings there might have been between these three men and the city whose interests they were commissioned to serve.

All we have about the selection of the street commissioners is the memorial from the Common Council to the state legislature recommending De Witt, Morris, and Rutherfurd “as fit and proper persons to be appointed.”

Newspaper reporting, other than surprisingly cursory announcements of the commission’s formation and its conclusion, is nonexistent. The archival record is of no more help. Rutherfurd and De Witt left no papers that amplify their roles. Even Morris’s voluminous personal papers for the period carry more details of his fishing exploits, dinner guests, and indispositions from gout and urinary blockage than the substance of his commission work. On Monday, June 29, 1807, Morris recorded in his diary: “Meet with Dewitt one of the Comm[issioners] and do business.” The specifics of the business on that early and presumably important day in their tenure, and on dozens of other days with similarly opaque entries over the intervening four years, is entirely unknown. On Thursday, March 28, 1811: “Raw damp and NEast Wind. Go to town on Business of the Comm[ission] to lay out Manhattan Island—Dine with Mr. Rutherford and execute the Maps—Much indisposed [from gout].” Thus, on the day Morris signed off on the great grid, we learn about the weather and his wellbeing, and nothing about the magnitude of the occasion. GK Show Less